DogFoodSelectorMAKE SENSE OF THEIR FOOD
Search
Find their food ↗

How We Review Dog Food

Our reviews help owners compare labels, food formats and buying arrangements. They are desk-based research unless a page explicitly describes genuine testing. We do not claim veterinary review where none has occurred.

What counts as a product fact?

We prioritise the current manufacturer declaration or the official retailer listing for that exact recipe and market. A review names the food or service, identifies the information source and records the research date. We separate the declared analysis from our editorial judgement about practical trade-offs.

What we do not infer

We do not turn a meat percentage, ingredient order or marketing phrase into a scientific quality score. We do not claim that a grain-free, fresh, raw or breed-labelled food is automatically superior. We do not describe commercial marketing terms as our own clinical endorsement.

Compare nutrition on the right basis

UK analytical constituents and US guaranteed minimums or maximums have different meanings. Water also affects percentages. Missing values stay unknown. A precise clinical comparison may need typical analysis or other information directly from the manufacturer.

How the selector works

The catalogue is deliberately limited to named, source-linked products. Matching checks the selected market, food format, adult stage and recorded ingredient exclusions. Breed, weight and activity are context rather than a validated quality ranking. Medical concerns, suspected allergies and puppies stop automatic recommendations. A match is not a guarantee that a food will suit the dog. How we match labels sets out each filter step by step.

Costs and commercial relationships

We publish a price only with enough context to identify the pack, market and observation date. Quotes, membership prices and introductory offers are distinguished. Missing prices are never treated as zero or within budget. Plain manufacturer links are not presented as affiliate partnerships. Any future paid link must carry a nearby disclosure.

Our review process, step by step

  1. Identify the exact product. We name the brand, recipe, pack and market (UK or US), because the same brand name can cover different recipes in different countries.
  2. Find the primary source. We use the manufacturer’s current label or product page, or the official retailer listing for that recipe, and record the date we checked it.
  3. Record the label as published. That means the complete or complementary statement, species and life stage, composition, analytical constituents (or the US guaranteed analysis), feeding guidance and any declared energy value. We do not fill gaps with estimates.
  4. Note what is unknown. If a label lists animal ingredients only by category, or a price, moisture or energy figure is missing, the review says so.
  5. Explain the practical trade-offs. Our editorial view covers who the format and routine may suit, storage, how to work out cost, and what to ask the manufacturer or your vet. We keep this separate from the declared facts.
  6. Link the checks. Each review points to the matching life-stage guide and to official recall sources, so readers can check for current safety notices.

What we check on every label

We read UK labels against the legal labelling particulars and the FEDIAF labelling code: whether the food is complete or complementary, the declared life stage, ingredient order and how ingredients are named, the declared percentage behind claims such as “with” or “rich in”, and the analytical constituents. US labels are read against the AAFCO guaranteed analysis, where protein and fat are minimums and fibre and moisture are maximums. How we match labels explains each of these, and why ingredient order is not a quality score.

Corrections and updates

Recipes, packs and prices change. A review reflects its sources on the date recorded, and we update it when we find a change. If you spot an outdated label, price or link, tell us and include the pack details if you can. Our affiliate disclosure explains how any paid links would be labelled.

Nutrition resources

Owner guidance: WSAVA nutrition resources. Calorie formulas: Merck Veterinary Manual. These sources do not endorse this website or its product selections.

Labelling sources: Regulation (EC) No 767/2009, Article 17 (legislation.gov.uk), the FEDIAF labelling code and AAFCO: reading labels.

Report an outdated label or correction · Recall resources · How we match labels · Best dog food in the UK

Who writes our pages

Pages are published under the byline Holly, the site’s editorial pen name. It is not the profile of a named individual, and it does not imply veterinary or nutrition qualifications or any veterinary review.